Common questions

How do you address a reviewer comment?


How do you address a reviewer comment?

Do’sConsult your coauthors or a colleague who is familiar with your work. Make sure that you address each of the comments in entirely. Be polite in your response when you disagree with any comment/suggestion.Wherever required, cite references, or include supplementary/unpublished data in support of your argument.

How do you write a response letter to a reviewer?

DO this:Recognize that the reviewers are volunteers and used their time to work hard on your paper. Respond to every single comment. For your convenience and the reviewers, it helps to number each comment. Keep your responses short, direct, and to the point. Always accept responsibility.

How do you respond to a reviewer comment Journal example?

I am/We are grateful to the reviewers for their insightful comments on my paper. I/We have been able to incorporate changes to reflect most of the suggestions provided by the reviewers. I/We have highlighted the changes within the manuscript.

How do you respond to reviewer comments the calm way?

How to respond to reviewer comments the CALM wayC: Comprehend (keep your cool!) When the decision letter arrives, read over the commentsTake time to understand the reviewers’ feedback and consider what they are asking you to do. A: Answer (amend or advocate!) L: List (make a list M: Mindful (make it easy for the editor they will appreciate it!)

Do reviewers see each others comments?

This means that EM supports the most common “open” peer review workflows where reviewers are allowed to see each other’s comments. So as to avoid confirmation bias, journals typically only share reviewer comments at time of decision.

How do you write a peer review?

DoJustify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.Be professional and respectful. Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!

What is the first step in the peer review process?

first stage in the peer-review process (see figure 1) is the editorial assessment process , during which the editor makes a decision whether the paper has potential for publication and should be sent to reviewers.

How do you write a peer review comment?

How to Write Helpful Peer Review CommentsAvoid decision fatigue. How many decisions have you made on an average day by 11AM? List the positives and then the negatives. Give concrete examples and advice. Don’t be afraid to seek support.

What do I write in a review?

Table of contentsProvide useful, constructive feedback.Talk about a range of elements, including customer service.Be detailed, specific, and honest.Leave out links and personal information.Keep it civil and friendly.Feel free to update your review if needed.Check you’ve got the right domain name or company.

How do you write a short review?

A review of a short story should include the following:Introduction. In the introduction, you should include some basic facts about the story, including the title, the author and the story genre. Summary. Briefly summarise the story. Personal reflection. Critical analysis. Conclusion.

How do you start off a review?

How To Write A Book Review: 6 Steps To TakeBegin with a brief summary of the book. This is probably the best way to introduce any review because it gives context. Pick out the most important aspects of the book. Include brief quotes as examples. Write a conclusion that summarises everything. Find similar books. Give it a star rating.

How do you write a good critical review?

Usual Structure of a Critical Reviewpresent the ideas in the original text accurately, ensuring you cover the main question the text attempts to address.discuss the important points, including the evidence the text uses to support the argument, and its conclusion.

How long does it take to write a 3000 word literature review?

It takes about 10 hours to write a 3,000 word essay.